Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 30th November 2008 Change Date

The Scotsman Digital Archive - Special Christmas Offer

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

'Cotton wool kids' to get adventure training



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 24 August 2008
EVERY teenager in Scotland will be given an annual "outdoor week" under a new plan to tackle the country's growing "cotton wool kid" culture.
The £10m-a-year scheme, which will be open to every 11 to 15-year-old in Scotland, is top of a "shopping list" of policy ideas which Conservative MSPs are to put before the Scottish government.

The SNP has already indicated its support for the pla
n, indicating that the pledge has enough backing to be pushed through Parliament.

Supporters of the outdoor activity scheme say it is required in a culture where the "cathedral space" of childhood is being reduced to a "shoebox".

It would guarantee all pupils at least one free, week-long outdoor adventure every year. The scheme has won the personal backing of former Scotland rugby captain Gavin Hastings, who said it would fill a void in the school curriculum.

Tory sources say the project was pencilled in during a private meeting of MSPs over the summer recess when they discussed their tactics in Parliament for the coming year.

Last year, in what was seen as a loose pact between the two parties, the Tories backed the SNP's budget after winning key policy concessions, including the speeding up of business rate cuts.

Tory leader Annabel Goldie came under fire for supporting the SNP budget, but the party leader insists that she will back Government plans that include measures they can support.

As a minority Government, the SNP require the backing of at least one of Labour, the Lib Dems or the Tories to get their plans through Parliament.

Tory insiders say that this year's "wish list" will be focused on the party's health and education policies, with the activity week at the top of the pile.

Other Conservative policies include a review of the controversial NHS 24 service, and a new system of "payment-by-results" in the NHS, under which patients would be able to choose the hospital where they get treated.

Alex Salmond is now putting the finishing touches to a new legislative programme to be unveiled next week.

A source close to the First Minister said: "We will publish our legislative programme when Parliament returns, and of course will look at ideas from wherever they come in the Parliament."

He added: "Of course, all opposition parties have to understand that in a fixed budget Parliament any extra spending in one area has to come from somewhere else – and they need to have the maturity to spell out these changes."

The plan for outdoor activity weeks was highlighted earlier this summer by Tory schools spokesman Liz Smith. She said: "This initiative would mean that every pupil in year groups P7-S3 should be entitled to a week's residential course in outdoor education."

"Education in an outdoor environment provides one of the most valuable and rewarding learning experiences for a wide range of pupils, regardless of background or ability.

"I firmly believe this would enrich the lives of the pupils, helping them to build confidence and self-esteem."

She added: "In particular, these activities teach pupils leadership skills, the need for responsible behaviour and how to deal with new challenges and risk factors."

Academics have been warning that countries across the western world are failing their children by giving in to excessive fears about the safety of the streets.

In Sweden, children under 11 were recently banned from cycling to school.

Former Scotland rugby captain Gavin Hastings has said that Scottish schools are "sorely lacking" such a scheme. He said he believed that most parents would welcome the scheme.

Under the Tory plans, the scheme would receive annual funding of £6m from the Scottish Government, with the remaining £4m coming from the private sector.

Scotland currently has four outdoor education centres, and these work with more than 20,000 youngsters a year.





The full article contains 648 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 24 August 2008 12:57 AM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Brian Hill,

24/08/2008 01:52:53
Excellent idea, but it will have minimum benefit if we continue to scare the sh#t out of mums at every opportunity with sensationalist headlines about danger which herds everyone into inactive SAFE mode.

Let's treat the problem but let's also treat the causes of the problem, viz artificially generated FEAR.
2

Cammy,

Edinburgh 24/08/2008 02:11:22
Very good proposal.

It's about time that our children had the free opportunity to experience some outdoor activities in Scotland.

It would be a real chance for them to give their PlayStations and MSN chatrooms a week off. You never know, they might even enjoy themselves. :-)

Of course these trips should not be compulsory, as a few may have their own personal issues and these should be respected.
3

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 24/08/2008 02:40:24

Don't believe for a moment the headline, "Cotton wool kids"!

There was I at our local shop yesterday evening, and there was two teen girls discussing, if they had enough money to purchase their chosen booze, which they appeared not to have, being a total rebel, I gave them the few needed bucks (pounds), to which they replied,..

"awe thanks"

Why Not!?, give them the few extra £s, on a Saturday night.

Resourceful "Teens", will only seek out the extra money needed for the booze elsewhere, the "elsewhere" might prove to be one of danger and detriment to them.

Thing IS! these soo called,...

" outdoor activity schemes", Will NOT teach the Child/Teen anything they don't know, that is going to be of detriment to them!

"Cotton wool kids" Are only the Few, that the Parents are to blame for.
4

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 24/08/2008 08:02:16
Surely a week in any of our sink schemes will toughen up these kids (those that survive it anyway)?
5

drunken proffet,

Tassy 24/08/2008 08:20:34
I think I must have lost track sometime in the last twenty or so years. You mean that the kids on Wednesday afternoon no longer have to get out on the field in all weather and train for rugby, football, cross country, hockey and other fiendish tortuous sports. I was obviously born before my time.
6

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 24/08/2008 08:57:17
#3 Charles Linskaill

Your post just sums up Scottish society today. (I'm presuming) a grown man sitting up in the middle of the night feeling proud enough of himself to let everyone else know he gives money to under age girls to buy alcohol. Rebel? I'm thinking more t**t.
7

Upbeat,

24/08/2008 09:27:02
Numbers of young people/teemagers in full time education in Scotland eligable to take part in such a scheme is ?

Number of weekly places at properly established outdoor education establishments in Scotland where the equipment /staff and facilities meet modern expectations for competance and qualification is ?

I think this wish list item can be seen for the "huff- puff" that it is.

That is not to say that children should not be exposed to challenges. But quite how these naive political dreamers consider that throwing money on its own to this ideal would deliver any advantage for Scottish young people was quite obviously not on the agenda.

8

Guga II,

Rockall 24/08/2008 09:47:25
Who, exactly, is going to have to fork out for this? Is this to be another burden on the taxpayers, forking out for holidays for kids whose parents can't be bothered organising things for their own.

This will end up being a taxpayer funded camp, where parents can get shot of the kids for a week so that they can swan off to the south of France or similar.
9

Boy Wonder,

24/08/2008 09:47:29
Chuckles Linskail is NOT a "rebel"! He's a 94 year old man with senile dementia and diminished responsibility.

If he did give kids money for booze, it shows how far he's gone!

I know kids drink. We all know that. The thing is not to make it easy for them, while trying to teach them how to drink responsibly! They wouldn't get my cash!

Nor would the 8 year old who asked if I had a spare ciggie yesterday! Utterly appalling! Even if I did smoke, there is not a snowball's chance in hell I'd supply a kid with any!

Bring sport back into the school curriculum and make it compulsory!!! Then at weekends, get your kids outdoors and do adventurous things WITH them. It's not the govt's place to make rthem healthy and fit ... it's YOURS!!!


10

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 24/08/2008 10:08:59
Many schools in the Highlands have provided "adventure weeks" for years and, whilst it is a useful and exciting week for the kids, it does nothing to reduce the yawning social gap between teenagers and the rest of the community which seems to increase with every generation.

The proposed budget is paltry and a single week of activities is surely not going to have a profound effect on children's social behaviour. It's a fact of life that teens will always question social boundaries and rebel against them whether by antisocial behaviour on the streets or closeting themselves away with a games console. It's one of the more uncomfortable things that keeps our society evolving.

Far better that the money be used to provide long term facilities that are accessible to all children (not just those in the central lowlands) with activities that can involve the whole community. For example, in the established shinty communities, the kids who play shinty generally enjoy a very good relationship with the adult population and it is the other teens that often feel alienated - probably with justification.

I'm not suggesting compulsory shinty for all! It's merely an example of something that works. There are plenty of other activities - from other sports to drama and the arts to voluntary work . . . even to computer game clubs - where those young rebellious minds and hormones can be diverted to good effect and enjoy an ongoing rewarding experience whilst making a satisfying contribution to their community.
11

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 24/08/2008 12:12:53
Ahah! The wonders of nostalgia! When back in the 50s we had 'sports', 'gardening', 'cookery', 'woodwork', 'metalwork', 'science' and such-like lessons!

But then, of course, Great Britain's Government was united in purpose and we manufactured 'things'.

Ah well! "Divided we fall"!
12

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 24/08/2008 13:28:55

Draco Was a Wimp #6,

Your the one saying that these girls were,....

....Quote; "under age girls", NOT ME!

To start with the shopkeeper would not sell them booze if one had been "under age"

Under 25 yes, but within the Law to purchase alcohol, at this present point in time.

I would not of given them a cent, if the CRAZED Politician's, had not proposed a Law out of mince for a brain, on banning under25s to purchase booze, which some supermarkets are now implementing.

'Aid and Abet' Too dammed RIGHT! and I will continue to do my damndest, to help the under 25s to get justice.
13

wattie>x 1,

PLYMOUTH 24/08/2008 20:27:03
I wonder whose children these "cotton wool kids" belong too?
Possibly "Family Value" Tory parents!
I doubt it very much after the Thatcher and Major era!
14

Maximus,

Roberton 24/08/2008 20:56:41
A most ridiculous idea ... spending money on events that will probably be risk assessed and still require parental consent.

How about parents being taught what it means to be a child, what a child needs, how these needs differ between boys and girls, promoting Guides and Scouts, promoting active parenting, male and female role models ... the list could go on.
15

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 24/08/2008 20:58:22

wattie>x 1 ~13,

EXACTALY!

"Cotton wool kids" Are only the Few, that the Parents are to blame for." re my comment #3.

As for Boy Wonder #9,

"They wouldn't get my cash!"

Thing is! 'NO-ONE' would "get his cash", he is a misery guts, who stores all his "Cash" under his Bed!
16

John PM,

Edinburgh 25/08/2008 14:11:43
The SNP are right and if the Tories want their proposals taken seriously they need to indicate where the money is coming from.

There is undoubtedly a problem in that kids are not allowed the freedom that they might have enjoyed in the past but the press share the blame for this by their constant dwelling on very occasional child murders and kidnapping.

There have always been holidays arranged through schools at places like Benmore, such should continue but the SNP have a tight budget thanks to Britgov and this will continue until we are independent.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.